S Corporation vs. LLC: Which is Better for Brokers?

If you run a brokerage in real estate, mortgage, or insurance, you already know that choosing the right business structure can feel like alphabet soup. LLCs, S corporations, partnerships, articles of organization, shareholder rules, reasonable compensation requirements, and state fees. It is a lot to take in when all you want is a structure that protects your personal assets and keeps more of your hard-earned income in your pocket.

The good news is that you really only need to compare two options: an LLC and a corporation. Both give you liability protection. Both can work for solo operators and growing teams. But they work very differently when it comes to taxes, payroll, profit distributions, and ongoing compliance.

Let’s break down how each structure works and what brokers should think about before choosing one for their business.

‍

What An LLC Really Means For Brokers

Most brokers start with an LLC because it is simple. You register with your state, set up a separate business account, and you are up and running. At its core, an LLC is simply a legal entity that provides its owners with protection if something goes wrong (hence the “limited liability” part of Limited Liability Company), without the complexities and maintenance requirements of a corporation. 

From a tax perspective, a single-member LLC is considered a disregarded entity. This means the IRS treats your business income the same way it treats a sole proprietorship. You report your profits on your personal tax return, and everything flows through to you directly. There is no separate corporate tax return required unless you elect otherwise.

This setup feels easy, but it is not always the most tax-efficient once the business grows. When you remain taxed as a sole proprietor via your LLC, your entire net income is subject to self-employment taxes (12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare, or 15.3% total!). For brokers who earn healthy commissions or run teams with multiple producers, this is a significant expense each year.

That said, many brokers choose LLCs because they want flexibility. LLCs offer greater flexibility in how profits are allocated, how the business is managed, and how partners come and go. If your brokerage has multiple revenue streams, varied ownership percentages, or fluctuating income, an LLC can be a very comfortable structure.

‍

What S Corporation Status Means And Why It Matters

An S corporation is not actually a type of legal entity. Instead, it is an election made by an LLC or corporation with the IRS, which grants a special tax status. LLCs and corporations that elect to be S corporations pass their corporate income, credits, and deductions through to their shareholders without paying federal corporate taxes.

Owners of S corporations who work for their company are required to pay themselves a fair wage. So, instead of paying self-employment tax on your entire profit, you split your earnings between a salary and distributions. The salary portion is taxed the same way as regular payroll. That means it is subject to federal income tax withholding, Social Security tax, and Medicare tax, all of which are tax-deductible expenses. You also have to run payroll through a proper system and file the required payroll reports.

The distribution portion works very differently. Distributions still count as income, but they are not subject to Social Security or Medicare taxes. This is where huge potential savings come from. By paying yourself a reasonable salary and taking the remaining profit as distributions, you limit the income subject to payroll taxes. For a profitable brokerage, that reduction can save thousands of dollars each year.

However, the IRS has rules you must follow. You must pay yourself a reasonable salary before taking distributions and running payroll. You must file the appropriate federal and state reports. You must follow corporate formalities more closely than a standard LLC.

For some brokers, this structure is absolutely worth the effort. For others, the administrative workload outweighs the savings. The key is knowing when your income level supports the switch.

‍

What Brokers Should Think About Before Choosing

Brokers are not like typical small businesses. Your income can swing from month to month. Some months you close several deals, other months you may close none. If you run a team, you are also responsible for commission payouts, marketing spend, lead generation, and cash flow planning.

That means your choice of entity matters more than you might think. Here are a few questions to consider.

1. How consistent are your profits?
   If your income is steady and comfortably profitable, S corporation taxation may save you money. If your income fluctuates heavily, the payroll requirement might feel too rigid.
   
   
2. Do you want to keep operations simple?
   Single-member LLCs that do not take the S election are easier to maintain—requiring less paperwork, fewer restrictions, and greater flexibility.
   
   
3. Do you expect to bring on partners or build a team?
   LLCs offer greater flexibility in ownership structures and profit allocation. Taking the S election introduces stricter rules on who can own shares of the business and how profits are distributed.
   
   
4. Do you invest in real estate outside your brokerage?
   Many brokers operate a separate LLC for property holdings and keep their brokerage entity distinct. Real estate inside an S corporation can create tax complications later.
   
   
5. Do you care more about tax savings or administrative ease?
   There is no wrong answer here. You simply need the structure that supports your business goals.
   
   

When An S Corporation Doesn’t Make Sense

‍Staying a single-member LLC is often the better choice when:

• You want simplicity and low maintenance.
• Your income is not yet high enough to justify the costs of running payroll, maintaining accurate financial statements, and other administrative expenses.
• You want flexibility with partners or branch structures.
• You hold real estate and want to keep those assets outside of a corporate structure.
• You prefer to avoid ownership restrictions and more rigid rules.

Many brokers start with an LLC and later elect S corporation taxation once their income becomes predictable. This allows them to enjoy flexibility early on and gain tax advantages later.

‍

When An S Corporation Becomes The Better Choice

‍An S corporation is often worth considering when:

• Your brokerage is consistently profitable.
• You are ready to take payroll and pay yourself a reasonable salary.
• You want to reduce your self-employment taxes by putting yourself on payroll.
• You have clean bookkeeping and strong financial systems in place.
• You want a structure that supports growth and more formal operations.

The switch does not have to be permanent. Many brokers reassess their legal and tax structures each year to ensure they still align with their goals.

‍

You Don’t Have To Decide Alone

Most brokers choose an entity structure once, then never revisit it. But your business is not static. Your income grows, your team expands, and your goals change. 

Your entity structure should evolve along with you.

At Bookkeeping for Brokers, we help mortgage brokers, real estate professionals, and insurance brokers understand their numbers clearly so they can choose the structure that fits their business today and supports where they want to go next. When your books are accurate and your financial reporting is tailored to your industry, choosing between an LLC and an S corporation becomes much clearer.

If you want support evaluating your structure or setting up financial systems that give you real clarity, we are here to help. ‍

Reach out to our team today, and let’s build financials that grow with your business.

‍