Why Mortgage Broker Profits Don’t Match Cash In The Bank

If you run a mortgage brokerage, you have probably had this moment before. You look at your profit and loss statement, and it shows a solid month. Closings were strong, revenue looks healthy, and on paper, the business is doing well. Then you log into your bank account and feel confused or frustrated because the cash balance does not reflect that success.

For many mortgage brokers, this cash flow problem comes down to commission timing, not a lack of profitability. This disconnect is one of the most common issues mortgage brokers face, especially as the business grows. It is not a sign that something is broken or that your brokerage is failing. In most cases, it is a timing and structure issue that comes from how mortgage revenue is earned, recorded, and collected.

Once you understand why profits and cash flow drift apart, you can start managing cash with much more confidence and far fewer surprises.

‍

Profit And Cash Flow Are Telling You Two Different Stories

Profit answers one question: did the business earn more than it spent during a period of time?

Cash flow answers a different question: how much money actually moved in and out of the bank?

In mortgage brokerages, these two answers often do not line up. Your books may show income when a loan closes or when commission is earned, even if the cash has not arrived yet. At the same time, expenses like payroll, rent, marketing, and software subscriptions are usually paid immediately.

That gap between when income is earned and when cash is received is the starting point for most mortgage broker cash flow stress.

A profitable brokerage can still feel cash tight if too much revenue is sitting in transit while bills keep coming due.

‍

Mortgage Broker Commission Timing: Revenue Often Hits The Books Before It Hits The Bank

Unlike many other service businesses, mortgage brokers frequently deal with delayed cash inflows. A loan may be operationally complete, but commission payments can take days or weeks to arrive depending on the lender, investor delivery timelines, post closing conditions, or internal processing.

When volume is steady, this delay can feel manageable. When volume fluctuates, or when several payments are delayed at once, the cash flow gap becomes obvious.

One thing that helps immediately is tracking two dates for every loan:

• The closing date
• The date cash is actually received

From there, you can calculate your average days from close to cash received. This single metric gives you visibility into commission timing and helps explain why the bank balance lags behind reported profit.

‍

Common Reasons Profitable Brokerages Feel Cash Poor

‍

Revenue Is Booked But Not Yet Collected

If your bookkeeping is done on an accrual basis, income is recorded when it is earned, not when it is paid. That means your profit and loss statement can look great even if a large portion of that revenue is still outstanding.

For mortgage brokers, this often shows up as lender payments that are expected but not yet received.

A simple fix is to treat outstanding lender payments with the same discipline as accounts receivable in other businesses. Maintain a clear list of closed loans, expected commission, cash received, and remaining balances. This turns vague cash flow anxiety into something measurable and manageable.

‍

Early Payoff Clawbacks Distort Reality

Early payoff clawbacks are a fact of life in mortgage brokerage. Revenue that looks solid today can reverse months later if a loan pays off early or violates lender terms.

If your books record the full commission upfront without accounting for this risk, profits can be overstated while cash flow slowly leaks out later.

A good approach is to build a chargeback reserve based on your historical experience. This does not need to be overly complex. Many brokerages reserve a percentage of commission income internally to reflect expected clawbacks. Over time, this creates a more realistic picture of what income is truly available to support cash flow.

‍

Payroll And Marketing Get Paid Before You Do

Loan officers, processors, and support staff expect to be paid on time. Marketing platforms and lead providers bill monthly. None of these vendors care whether lender payments have cleared yet.

When commissions or draws are paid immediately on close, but revenue arrives later, the business funds the timing gap out of its own cash flow. During strong month,s this feels fine. During slower or uneven months, it can become painful very quickly.

Even if you cannot change compensation timing, forecasting the gap makes it far less stressful. Knowing that you are always operating with a two or three-week lag helps you plan cash flow instead of reacting to it.

‍

Balance Sheet Items Quietly Absorb Cash

Many mortgage brokers focus almost entirely on the profit and loss statement and rarely look at the balance sheet. This is where cash flow problems often hide.

Items like unpaid bills, accrued payroll, reimbursable expenses, or funds passing through the business can all distort the cash picture. None of these necessarily hurt profitability, but they absolutely affect cash flow.

Reviewing changes in receivables, payables, and accruals each month helps explain where cash actually went.

‍

A Simple Way To Diagnose The Cash Flow Gap

You do not need a complex financial model to understand why cash flow and profit do not match. A short monthly review often reveals the answer.

Start with your net income for the month, then look at what changed on the balance sheet:

• Did outstanding lender payments increase or decrease?
• Did unpaid bills go up or get paid down?
• Did accrued payroll or commissions move?
• Did owner draws increase?

When you adjust profit for these changes, you arrive at net cash from operations. This number often explains the entire gap between a strong P&L and a weak bank balance.

Running this exercise monthly turns mortgage broker cash flow from a mystery into a repeatable process.

‍

Why Cash Flow Forecasting Is Essential For Mortgage Brokers

Due to built-in commission timing delays, cash flow forecasting is not optional for mortgage brokers. It is a core management tool.

A simple 13-week cash flow forecast is often enough. It should include:

• Expected lender payments by week based on historical commission timing
• Payroll and commission payouts
• Fixed operating expenses
• Known one-time costs
  
  

This forecast does not need to be perfect; it just needs to be realistic. Even a rough view of future cash flow gives you time to adjust spending, delay non-essential costs, or plan draws responsibly.

Many brokerages also benefit from separating cash into two buckets: an operating account for daily activity and a reserve account for chargebacks, slow periods, and surprises. This adds discipline without adding complexity.

‍

What Healthy Cash Flow Looks Like In A Mortgage Brokerage

Healthy cash flow is not about always having a massive bank balance. It is about predictability and control.

Strong mortgage brokerages tend to monitor a small set of cash flow-focused metrics:

• Average days from close to cash received
• Total outstanding lender payments
• Chargeback rate and reserve coverage
• Net cash from operations
• Payroll as a percentage of collected commission, not just booked commission

These numbers create clarity and help leadership make decisions with confidence.

‍

Bringing It All Together

With the right visibility, the gap in cash coming in and going out becomes manageable. Tracking commission timing, building realistic reserves, reviewing the balance sheet, and forecasting cash flow ahead can transform how the business feels day to day.

This is where Bookkeeping for Brokers comes in. We work with mortgage brokers to handle the day-to-day bookkeeping, accounting, and ongoing cash flow oversight that keeps the numbers accurate and useful.

With the right reporting and cash flow forecasting in place, you no longer have to guess whether a strong month will actually show up in your bank account. You can see it coming, plan for it, and make better decisions.

If you want help getting clarity around your mortgage broker cash flow and commission timing, book a call with us to review how your money is currently moving and where small changes could make a meaningful difference.